We’ve held off for what feels like ages, yet the signs of autumn are everywhere and we’re finally giving in. It might be our perpetual FOMO talking, but we’ve been sweetening our mornings with cinnamon-infused coffee and rewatching fall favorites to get into the season. A perennial choice this time of year is Practical Magic, and with its sequel landing today, the moment feels perfectly timed.
We hadn’t expected our beloved prebiotic soda maker Olipop to unveiling a fall-themed flavor today either, especially not in collaboration with one of Practical Magic 2’s leading stars. Maisie Williams, known for her role in Game of Thrones, appears as the daughter of Sandra Bullock’s character in the film and fronts this Olipop campaign. The new flavor is pitched as a caramel apple experience, a fall staple that sounds irresistible but also raises questions about how true to the idea it will be. Skepticism is warranted with seasonal offerings, yet we tested it anyway to determine what works and where it trips. Here’s our take.
Our Official Sporked Review
Pros — The most compelling aspect here is the dedication not only to the flavor but to the entire season. The can design feels more interactive and engaging than Olipop’s other varieties, a detail we’d love to see echoed in future launches from the brand.
As with most Olipop beverages, the carbonation is pleasantly calibrated, a detail many overlook but which contributes significantly to the overall experience. The fizz isn’t aggressive enough to blast up your sinuses, yet it still provides a lively sparkle that enhances the sipping moment.
Cons — Regrettably, the downsides outweigh the positives for this one. The caramel flavor overwhelms the profile with an artificial sweetness that resembles the cloying bite of candy butterscotch, effectively drowning out the intended tart apple notes that should come through in each sip.
There’s also a tendency for the flavor to amplify the stevia, leaving an aftertaste that felt unpleasant enough to warrant chasing it with something neutral. On balance, this seasonal offering doesn’t quite deliver the festive spirit we hoped to savor.
