Our Official Thoughts
Pros — In my view, shortbread cookies can be a true hit or miss, depending on how generously buttered they are. When the butter is sparse, they end up tasting like a plain sugar cookie, and if they come out too dry, the experience becomes rather uncomfortable. Fortunately, these cookies avoid those pitfalls and actually surpass what we anticipated. When shortbread is done well (as these are) it stands out as a standout dessert. It’s not news that Costco’s bakery section tends to pull off reliable recipes, and these certainly impressed us with what they offered.
Not only is the texture tender and delicate, but they don’t rely on underbaking to achieve that effect. Moreover, the true butter flavor sits front and center, something we particularly value as the holiday season approaches. Even more, that rich, buttery profile is balanced by smooth, luscious Belgian chocolate of high quality, elevating these cookies to a pinnacle of indulgence.
Cons — I know Costco’s model revolves around offering goods in bulk at a lower price, yet with these cookies I feel that this volume aspect is unnecessary. A box containing 15 cookies seems excessive and could cause the flavor to become repetitive rather than as engaging as the first few bites. They might be ideal as part of a mixed assortment rather than on their own. That said, if you’re drawn to these cookies and have a practical reason to stock that many, I would still give them a solid recommendation.
