As Thanksgiving draws nearer, Crumbl is leaning into pies and other classic desserts to spark cookie-flavor ideas. Yet, among everything on the weekly menu, the item that truly caught our eye was the French Silk Pie. Of all the pie varieties offered, we believe the French silk pie is markedly underrated for what it is and deserves a longer moment in the spotlight.
Our Official Take
The most frustrating aspect of this treat is that, despite several attempts to salvage non-cookie items on Crumbl’s menu, they consistently miss the mark. It feels inherently odd to replace Crumbl’s signature Cookies with non-cookie options in the first place, and these items invariably reveal either insufficient attention during development or a gap in nationwide execution relative to the brand’s standard.
The reality is simple: people come to Crumbl for cookies. If a non-cookie entry makes it onto the menu, it should be entirely deserving of the attention it garners. This French Silk Pie reads like another instance where a cookie would have been a better fit. There isn’t a single element here that justifies taking a cookie off the lineup. Is it awful or unattractive? No. But is it merely another Oreo-centered dessert from Crumbl—a pretentious chocolate pudding in disguise? Yes. It lacks balance and any redeeming qualities that would make it a worthwhile choice.
Truth be told, it felt somewhat like eating a dirt cake, albeit with less zest and more blandness. But to be fair, the mousse texture did have a pleasant side to it. It wasn’t at all akin to the texture a genuine French Silk Pie should possess, yet it wasn’t unenjoyable. The lingering question remains why this brand feels compelled to offer alternative desserts when the rest of the “pies” featured this week were pie-inspired cookies that at least align with Crumbl’s concept.