If you don’t call the mid-Atlantic home, I truly feel for you. Not because New York, Pennsylvania, and New Jersey aren’t remarkable—it’s simply that you don’t get Wegmans. Ask anyone within Wegmans’ radius and you’ll hear that it’s by far their preferred grocery store. Step inside and you’re welcomed by gentle, warm illumination and the aroma of freshly cut blossoms. Your first visit to a Wegmans can feel like returning home after a long, arduous journey.
While Wegmans stands out for its stellar produce and boasts an impressive cheese department staffed by a real cheesemonger, its store-brand selections in the middle aisles deserve attention too. As a regular shopper at my neighborhood Wegmans, I’ve put together a roster of my top picks and those that consistently receive strong praise from shoppers. These are the items worth choosing over the national brands.
Ultra-Smooth Oat Milk with Extra Creaminess
I used to reach for Oatly or Chobani when I wanted a versatile oat milk, but those days ended once I found Wegmans’ Ultra-Creamy Oat Milk. It isn’t as decadently rich as the top-brand options, yet it lends a half-and-half-like silkiness to coffee, remains refreshing on its own or as cereal milk, and costs a fraction of the price of the big-name rivals. I even whisk in a splash to curries to boost richness without weighing down the dish.
Amore Organic Tomato and Basil Pasta Sauce
I love making sauce from scratch, yet I think everyone should have a reliable jarred option for spontaneous pasta nights or a lazy craving. This Wegmans jar fills that role—a quintessential pasta sauce. The basil stands out, yet remains gentle enough to pass for a classic marinara. It’s tasty on its own and balanced—not overly sweet or tangy. For a quick upgrade, stir in roasted garlic cloves and brighten with black pepper and crushed red pepper, and nobody would suspect it’s from a jar.
Ginger-Infused Sparkling Water
Wegmans’ seltzers vary in quality, but the ginger flavor is worth noting for fans of the spicy-sweet root. Ginger-based sparkling waters are rare, and many taste overly tart. Wegmans’ take tastes like unsweetened ginger ale, offering bold flavor without any syrupy sweetness. I occasionally drizzle in a small amount of agave to give it a livelier edge.
Maple-Cream Cookies
I’m drawn to anything maple-flavored and to sweets that look charming, so these cookies hit two birds with one stone. They’re appealing on a fall party spread or set beside a steaming cup of cocoa or hot cider. They carry a robust maple taste and strike a satisfying crunch without being rough on teeth. The cookie-to-filling balance is spot-on—a rarity among generic snacks.
Donut Shop Blend: Organic Whole-Bean Coffee
Being something of a coffee snob, I only buy Wegmans’ Donut Shop Blend when it comes to store-bought coffee. It arrives in a chunky two-pound bag to satisfy even the most devoted caffeine aficionado, and it’s both whole-bean and organic—a rarity among house-brand coffees. The brew tastes fresh, is light-bodied, with a hint of zest and fruitiness—the ideal morning cup to kickstart the day.