Five autumn flavors hitting an ice cream shop might sound a bit perilous. Yet it’s a smart move, especially as chilly days settle in and visitors seek something a little comforting. I’m not pretending I don’t notice—there I am, outside Jeni’s, ready to sample the five new fall flavors the shop rolled out this week. Let’s dive in and dish it all out.
Hazelnut Stracciatella
Pros: The hazelnut character comes through with real intensity. It’s ideal for anyone who absolutely loves hazelnut flavors and wants them to be front and center.
Cons: If hazelnut isn’t your top obsession, this scoop may feel a bit overwhelming; it dominates the bowl and lingers on the palate well after you’ve moved on to the next flavor.
Rating: 5/10
Salty Caramel
Pros: For fall, this salty caramel acts as the dependable choice at Jeni’s. It stays true to its promise by delivering caramel ice cream with a balanced hint of salt—reliable and satisfying.
Cons: It lacks depth and there aren’t additional textures or mix-ins to discover. It’s a straightforward, consistent salty caramel all the way through, which lowers its wow factor a notch.
Rating: 6/10
Pear Frangipane
Pros: This scoop stands out as the most flavorful in the lineup, with pear sweetness carried throughout. It’s bright, true to pear, and I found it pairs beautifully with the salty caramel as Jeni’s suggests, creating a memorable contrast.
Cons: Personal taste comes into play here—while pear-forward, it may feel a bit repetitive toward the end for those who aren’t pear enthusiasts.
Rating: 8/10
Pumpkin with Brown Sugar Blondies
Pros: This creation captures that pumpkin pie vibe with warm spice, delivering exactly what you’d expect from a pumpkin-spice ice cream. It’s elevated by the presence of brown sugar blondies, which add a comforting, dessert-like balance.
Cons: The pumpkin and accompanying spices can be a little overpowering, masking the blondie’s presence. While it may seem like a misnomer, the scoop remains a delicious fall treat.
Rating: 8.5/10
Miso Butterscotch Brownie
Pros: This one is exceptionally delicious—savory miso meets sweet butterscotch and chocolate brownie in a surprising, delightful harmony. The miso lends a playful umami that complements the brownie, allowing the butterscotch to shine through.
Cons: There aren’t notable drawbacks—snag this flavor as soon as you can!
Rating: 10/10
