At Crumbl this week, there isn’t a formal theme, yet it’s fair to say we’re showcasing a robust lineup of beloved flavors. From cookies and cream to Dubai chocolate, there’s a little something for every preference. And as always, we’re keen to wade into the taste-testing pool and sample at least one of the rotating picks.
Our Official Thoughts
Pros — To begin with, let’s clear one thing up: if Fruity Pebbles isn’t your thing, this cookie probably won’t win you over. The Fruity Pebbles flavor permeates every single bite. For fans of fruity cereal, we were impressed by how steady and uniform that flavor remained throughout each mouthful. It wasn’t merely a few pieces used as garnish; the cookie is encircled by a genuine coating of cereal pieces. Not only did we value that flavor, but the texture it introduces to the cookie is delightful. They’re light and crisp, providing a pleasing contrast to the tender, warm cookie beneath.
And perhaps the most appealing element is the glaze itself. It isn’t so much about a distinctly bold flavor, but rather the contrast it creates with Crumbl’s typical cookie style that we found striking. With the buttercream frosting topping that most Crumbl cookies sport, the texture can feel heavy and overpowering when paired with the sweet, dense cookies. This glaze, however, gives the cookie a chance to let the Fruity Pebbles’ texture and taste truly shine.
Maybe it’s just the recent batch we’ve chosen for tasting, but Crumbl seems to be moving toward adding more balance and nuance to their cookies. A key method is evident in this cookie as well: a generous pinch of salt. The occasional salt note helps the flavors sing, even when they’re simple, child-like flavors.
Cons — The oddest aspect might be that this cookie simultaneously feels incredibly tender and somewhat stale. While it’s so warm that it almost crumbles in your hands due to its softness, the Fruity Pebbles’ crispness tends to go stale as time passes. If you don’t plan to eat it immediately, the cereal texture can become noticeably unpleasant in combination with the rest of the cookie.
